School Board Member Warns Inclusion Pledge Could Open Door to Controversial Lessons

This is a controversy is playing out at schools across the country.

WALLED LAKE, Mich. (Sept. 5, 2025) — The Walled Lake Consolidated Schools Board of Education opened its recent meeting with a statement of support for all students and staff, but the message immediately drew disagreement from one board member.

Board President Stephanie Kaplan read a prepared statement that emphasized the district’s commitment to welcoming students of all backgrounds.

“While Walled Lake Consolidated Schools and all members of the school board administration fully support all of our students and staff, regardless of your race, color, national origin, disability, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender or gender identity,” Kaplan said. “Furthermore, Walled Lake Consolidated Schools and all members of the school board administration support the free expression of ideas and believe that it is important to expose students to a wide variety of educational topics, which includes ensuring that the curriculum and the libraries include materials that make students feel safe and included.”

Before Kaplan spoke, board member Lisa West said she could not agree with the full statement.

“I do not fully agree with the public statement that President Kaplan’s about to make,” West said. “I do not support all that comes within today’s culture. I believe it discriminates against my faith and that of many across our district who elected me to represent them.”

This is story the media has NOT covered. I left the mainstream media to give you the real news. If you are not already and can do so I ask you to become a paid subscriber to support my independent journalism. Click red button below.

West added that she does not believe providing materials to students is the same as creating safety.

“I do not believe that providing materials provides a safe space when in reality it is being confused with wanting affirmation of who they are,” she said. “I believe that providing materials to minors can create confusion.”

National Policy Context

The discussion in Walled Lake reflects a broader national debate. Since returning to office in January, President Donald Trump has signed a series of executive orders aimed at reshaping how schools handle issues of identity and instruction.

• One order, called Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling, prohibits schools from teaching what the administration describes as “gender ideology” or critical race theory. Schools found in violation risk federal funding cuts or legal consequences.

• Other orders eliminated federal offices that promoted race- or gender-based programs, and required universities to disclose admissions data by race.

• Trump has also said schools should return to what he calls “traditional education,” focusing on reading, writing, math, and civics. He argues that classroom time should not be used for what he describes as cultural or political agendas.

Critics say the policies limit local control and silence important perspectives, while supporters argue they restore fairness and protect parental rights.

Local Impact

For Walled Lake, Kaplan’s remarks and West’s objections show how national discussions about education policy are now filtering down into suburban Michigan classrooms. The board’s approach to inclusion, curriculum, and library materials is expected to remain a point of community discussion in the months ahead.