What is the open fields doctrine?
LANSING, Mich. — As Michigan hunters prepare for the opening of firearm deer season, a legal battle is underway that could have significant implications for private property owners across the state.
Michigan attorney Philip Ellison of Outside Legal Counsel is challenging the ability of Michigan Department of Natural Resources conservation officers to enter private property without a search warrant while investigating potential hunting and fishing violations.
In an interview with Dave Bondy, Ellison said he is asking the Michigan Court of Claims to determine whether the practice violates the Michigan Constitution.
“We’ve asked a Michigan judg known as the “open fields doctrine.”
Under federal constitutional law, the doctrine generally allows law enforcement officers to search areas outside a home and its immediate surroundings without obtaining a warrant, even when the land is privately owned.
Those areas can include wooded property, farmland and private hunting grounds.
Ellison argues that the Michigan Constitution provides broader protections than the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
Specifically, he points to Article I, Section 11 of the Michigan Constitution, which protects a person’s “possessions,” while the Fourth Amendment uses the word “effects.”
Ellison argues that the distinction should extend constitutional protections to privately owned hunting land.
Newaygo County couple at center of lawsuit
Ellison represents a Newaygo County couple who he said experienced a warrantless visit from a DNR conservation officer investigating potential violations.
According to Ellison, the officer made several accusations and threatened criminal charges. The local prosecutor ultimately did not file charges stemming from the encounter.
However, Ellison said the incident left the property owners feeling vulnerable and concerned that government officials could enter their land whenever they wanted.
The couple subsequently filed a lawsuit in the Michigan Court of Claims.
Ellison said the final legal briefs were filed this week, and the case is now awaiting a ruling.
Pennsylvania ruling could influence Michigan case
Ellison said a recent court ruling in Pennsylvania could strengthen his argument.
According to Ellison, a Pennsylvania court determined that the state’s constitutional protections extend to private hunting property, rejecting the application of the federal open fields doctrine under that state’s constitution.
Ellison said he included the Pennsylvania decision in his latest court filings.
Attorneys representing the Michigan DNR, however, have argued that the Pennsylvania ruling should not apply in Michigan, according to Ellison.
Attorney says lawsuit is about government accountability
Ellison emphasized that the lawsuit is not intended to prevent conservation officers from enforcing Michigan’s hunting and fishing laws.
Instead, he said officers should be required to demonstrate probable cause to a judge before conducting criminal searches on private property.
“The whole point of all this is not to say that law enforcement can’t do its job,” Ellison said. “Of course they can do their job.”
He argues that requiring a warrant provides an important safeguard against potential government overreach.
Case could reach Michigan Supreme Court
Regardless of how the Michigan Court of Claims rules, Ellison anticipates the losing side will appeal.
The case could ultimately reach the Michigan Supreme Court, potentially establishing a precedent affecting private property owners, hunters and conservation officers throughout the state.
A ruling in favor of the property owners could significantly change how conservation officers conduct investigations on private land.
Attorney wants to hear from other Michigan hunters
Ellison is encouraging Michigan residents who have experienced warrantless searches of their private property by conservation officers to contact him.
He has established a website where property owners can learn more about the legal challenge and share their experiences.
Ellison said the case ultimately comes down to establishing the boundaries of government authority and protecting the constitutional rights of Michigan residents.
The Michigan DNR’s position is described in this article based on Ellison’s account of the litigation. The department was not independently interviewed for this article.


How is this even Federally constitutional? This sounds like serious gov overreach. And if it is a "rule" as opposed to a law, doesn't that mean that it is bound not just by our MI constitution but our founding principals as well?