Alpena School Board Bans Clapping at Meetings, Prompting First Amendment Debate

Community members say applause is free speech, but board insists ban is needed to maintain order.

ALPENA, Mich. — A new rule banning applause and other displays of emotion at Alpena Public Schools board meetings has sparked pushback from community members who say the policy infringes on their free speech rights.

The board recently adopted a policy prohibiting clapping, cheering, booing, or any demonstrations from audience members during meetings. Board President Eric Lawson said the restriction is meant to prevent disruptions and maintain order.

“We’re doing our best to show respect to you all and make sure you have adequate time for your comments,” Lawson said during a recent meeting. “Please show the board a little respect as well.”

👉 If you’ve been reading for free, know this work exists because of paid subscribers — I can’t do it without them, and I’d be honored if you joined them today. Click red link below to support for less than $1 per week.

Not everyone in attendance agreed. Several residents voiced frustration, including one woman who argued that clapping constitutes symbolic speech protected under the First Amendment.

“Clapping is a universal symbolic action that typically expresses approval,” she said. “Up until one week ago, clapping was a regular occurrence at these meetings and could not have been argued as substantially disruptive.”

Despite Lawson’s repeated reminders, some audience members continued to clap in protest. Police officers were present at the meeting, but no one was removed or arrested.

The dispute reflects a broader tension seen in school board meetings across the country, where officials have struggled to balance public participation with maintaining order.

For now, Alpena residents appear determined to keep their hands together.